Stephen Hawking loved to make bets. One of his most famous was a wager made in 1997 with Kip Thorne and John Preskill (both at Caltech) on what happens to information entering a black hole. Hawking bet that the information is lost forever—prevented by the rules of general relativity from ever escaping. Thorne sided with Hawking, while Preskill took the opposing side, upholding the principle of quantum mechanics that says information can never be truly destroyed.
This debate, referred to as the black hole information paradox, had its origin in a 1976 paper [1], where Hawking pointed out a problematic implication of black hole radiation—an idea that he had proposed two years earlier. According to that idea, a black hole will continuously emit thermal radiation, losing mass as it does. Eventually, the black hole will evaporate completely. Hawking realized a problem with this: The “stuff” that went into creating the black hole carried information about the states of all the particles it contained. In the picture of black holes imposed by general relativity, this information can never get back out of the black hole—and so when the black hole vanishes from the Universe, so does all that information. This disappearance conflicts with a basic principle of quantum mechanics, called unitarity, which insists that information is never lost.
Hawking originally thought that relativity wins out. But he ended up conceding defeat in 2004, giving Preskill the wagered prize: an encyclopedia of baseball. It was never clear, though, that his change of heart was based on any compelling scientific argument—it seemed more of a hunch. So even after Hawking’s concession, the issue wasn’t considered to have been definitively settled, and the paradox remains debated today. Yet the quest for a resolution has proved tremendously fertile, illuminating new connections between general relativity, quantum mechanics, information theory, and thermodynamics.
To read more, click here.